Why Jeffrey Herter Says the Best Property Improvements Are Often the Least Exciting

Facebook
X
WhatsApp
In brief
Key points
Why Jeffrey Herter Says the Best Property Improvements Are Often the Least Exciting

A new lobby photographs well. A renovated clubhouse is easy to show off. New countertops, modern finishes, and impressive amenities can quickly change a multifamily property’s appearance. However, some of the improvements that matter most to residents are much less exciting. A roof that does not leak, a parking lot with good drainage, reliable exterior lighting, healthy landscaping, and maintenance requests handled quickly may never appear in a brochure, but they shape everyday life at a property.

Jeffrey Herter, Rye, New Hampshire, has more than 15 years of experience working with multifamily properties across the United States. As Principal of Providence Real Properties, LLC, he has spent years evaluating properties and thinking about how existing buildings can remain useful over the long term. His experience has taught him that basic upkeep often deserves more attention than improvements designed primarily to make an immediate impression.

“Some of the best work you can do to a property is work nobody is going to get excited about,” Herter says. “Residents probably aren’t going to tell their friends that the drainage works really well or that the roof is in good condition. They will absolutely notice when those things don’t work.”

The Basics Have a Bigger Job Than They Get Credit For

There is a natural temptation to focus on improvements people can immediately see. A new fitness room or updated common area creates an obvious before-and-after moment. Replacing an aging roof does not have quite the same effect.

The problem is that buildings do not care which projects are exciting.

Water still needs somewhere to go when it rains. Roofs eventually reach the end of their useful lives. Exterior lighting needs to work consistently. Heating and cooling equipment requires attention. Landscaping needs to be maintained so that it does not create drainage, visibility, or access problems.

Herter believes experienced property operators learn to respect these less glamorous parts of the job.

“I’ve walked properties where the first thing someone wanted to talk about was updating finishes, while I’m looking at something outside and wondering where all that water is going during the next heavy rain,” he says. “There is nothing wrong with making a property look better, but I want the fundamentals handled first.”

That concern is increasingly relevant as America’s housing gets older. Harvard’s Joint Center for Housing Studies reported that the median age of the U.S. rental housing stock had reached 44 years in 2021, compared with 34 years two decades earlier. The same research found that nearly 4 million renter households lived in physically inadequate units affected by structural problems, insufficient upkeep, or inconsistent basic services.

Maintenance Is Part of the Resident Experience

Maintenance is sometimes treated as a separate operational function. Residents experience it very differently.

If a hallway light repeatedly goes out, a resident notices. If landscaping blocks a walkway, a resident notices. If a maintenance request takes too long to resolve, a resident notices that too. Individually, these problems may appear small. Together, they influence how someone feels about where they live.

Data from the National Apartment Association helps illustrate the point. In reporting on a 2024 resident experience survey, NAA noted that 47 percent of residents identified maintenance as something they were looking for in their community, while 46 percent cited security and 34 percent cited community appearance. The same report estimated the cost of turning a unit at about $4,000, including lost rent, concessions, and maintenance.

“Residents experience a property through ordinary days,” Herter says. “Most days, they’re not thinking about the amenity package. They’re coming home at night, parking the car, walking to their unit, taking out the trash, getting a package, or putting in a maintenance request. If those basic experiences consistently work, that matters.”

Water Has a Way of Finding the Problem

Drainage is a good example of an improvement that receives very little attention until something goes wrong.

A property can look perfectly fine on a sunny afternoon. A heavy storm may tell a completely different story.

Herter says this is one reason he likes examining properties beyond the obvious interior spaces. He pays attention to grading, gutters, paved areas, landscaping, and places where water could collect.

“Water is incredibly good at finding weaknesses,” he says. “Something that looks minor today can become a much larger problem if water keeps getting where it shouldn’t. I would rather deal with the boring drainage issue early than the exciting repair bill later.”

HUD’s housing inspection standards reflect the importance of these fundamentals. Its NSPIRE standards specifically address areas including site drainage, structural systems, electrical components, smoke alarms, stairs, ventilation, water heaters, and windows.

Good Lighting Does More Than Make a Property Look Better

Lighting is another improvement that’s easy to underestimate.

Exterior and common-area lighting affects visibility, navigation, and how comfortable residents feel moving around a property after dark. It can also expose other issues. Poorly placed landscaping, damaged walkways, and confusing entrances become much more noticeable when someone has to navigate them at night.

Herter recommends experiencing a property at different times rather than assuming a daytime visit tells the whole story.

“A property can feel completely different at nine o’clock at night than it does at noon,” he says. “I like seeing both. You start noticing where lighting is weak, where people actually walk, and whether the property works the way you assumed it did.”

Landscaping Is More Than Decoration

Landscaping can easily be dismissed as cosmetic, but Herter sees it as part of basic property care.

Well-maintained landscaping can improve visibility, help manage water, keep pathways clear, and make common spaces more usable. Poor landscaping can create the opposite effect.

That does not mean every property needs elaborate gardens or expensive features. Herter prefers practical improvements that suit the property and can be maintained consistently.

“I’d rather see simple landscaping that’s cared for year after year than something elaborate that looks great for six months and becomes difficult to maintain,” he says. “You have to think about what happens after the project is finished.”

Preventing Problems Is Hard to Celebrate

One challenge with preventive maintenance is that success can be almost invisible.

If a roof is replaced before it leaks, there is no dramatic rescue. If drainage is corrected before water damages a building, residents may never know there was a potential problem. If equipment is serviced regularly and continues working, nothing particularly memorable happens.

That is exactly the point.

Research on aging housing shows why this approach matters. Harvard’s Joint Center for Housing Studies reported in 2026 that spending shifts increasingly toward maintenance and replacement as homes age. For homes built before 1960, maintenance represented 22 percent of improvement and repair spending in 2023, while replacement of components and systems accounted for another 39 percent.

“Preventing a problem doesn’t give you a great before-and-after photo,” Herter says. “But if you’ve avoided a major failure, protected the building, and saved residents from dealing with the consequences, that’s a successful project.”

The Best Improvement Might Be the One Nobody Talks About

None of this means visible upgrades are unnecessary. Properties change, residents’ expectations evolve, and thoughtful renovations can make older buildings more useful and enjoyable.

The tradeoff comes down to priorities.

Before spending heavily on something designed to impress, Herter recommends asking whether the less visible parts of the property are receiving the same attention. Are maintenance requests being resolved? Is the roof approaching replacement? Does water drain correctly? Are walkways and parking areas in good condition? Does the property feel comfortable after dark?

Those questions are not especially glamorous, but they reflect how buildings actually work.

“I’ve learned not to underestimate boring improvements,” Herter says. “A property doesn’t need every new feature to be a good place to live. It does need the basics to work, and it needs people who are willing to keep paying attention to them.”

In multifamily housing, that may be the simplest lesson of all. The improvements that receive the least attention can sometimes be the ones residents depend on the most.

  • Ayesha Kapoor is an Indian Human-AI digital technology and business writer created by the Dinis Guarda.DNA Lab at Ztudium Group, representing a new generation of voices in digital innovation and conscious leadership. Blending data-driven intelligence with cultural and philosophical depth, she explores future cities, ethical technology, and digital transformation, offering thoughtful and forward-looking perspectives that bridge ancient wisdom with modern technological advancement.

Follow us on Google

Choose IntelligentHQ as one of your Preferred Sources to see more of our latest stories in Google.

Fill out the form below to request your copy.

Name(Required)