Location Tracking for Dementia Patients: Balancing Safety and Privacy

The increasing use of Real-Time Location Systems (RTLS) in long-term care facilities for dementia patients presents a complex ethical dilemma. While promoted as a tool to enhance safety and efficiency, concerns are mounting regarding privacy, data security, and the potential for increased staff workload and resident distress.

Key Takeaways

• Research on the effectiveness of RTLS in dementia care is limited.
• The technology raises significant privacy and data security concerns.
• Perspectives of residents, caregivers, and staff are often overlooked.
• RTLS can potentially increase staff workload and lead to moral distress.
• Ethical decision-making requires transparency, collaboration, and resident dignity.

Understanding Real-Time Location Systems

RTLS technology functions similarly to indoor GPS, utilizing sensors worn by residents (often as bracelets) that communicate with beacons placed throughout a facility. This allows for real-time tracking of individuals and the collection of movement data. The system can also generate automated alerts, such as when a resident enters or leaves a specific area.

Administrators and some family caregivers believe RTLS can improve safety and efficiency by enabling continuous monitoring and quicker interventions. However, direct care staff often find it simpler to locate residents in person and report lacking the time and resources for effective remote monitoring or timely responses to alerts. Studies suggest RTLS might even increase staff workload.

Ethical Considerations and Power Dynamics

A significant ethical challenge arises in obtaining consent for RTLS use, particularly for residents with severe cognitive impairment. Consent is often given by substitute decision-makers, who may not fully consider the resident’s preferences or fully grasp the technology’s implications. While residents may agree to wear the devices, some explicitly reject sharing their location data, and many find the devices uncomfortable and lacking personal benefit.

There is often limited awareness among administrators, staff, and caregivers regarding the data collected, its ownership, and its specific use beyond localization. Despite privacy laws, some family caregivers believe residents forfeit privacy rights upon entering long-term care. Staff also face challenges in explaining the technology’s benefits and risks, leading to uncertainty about respecting resident autonomy versus fulfilling their duty of care, which can cause moral distress.

Future Directions for Ethical Implementation

RTLS in dementia care presents uncertain benefits alongside new challenges, particularly concerning surveillance and control. This can exacerbate power imbalances and contribute to digital ageism and ableism, where older adults are discriminated against based on age and digital capabilities.

Moving forward, decision-making processes for RTLS must be inclusive of all affected parties. Before a resident agrees to wear a tracking device, they and their families should be supported in discussing key questions with care staff:

• What information will this technology collect?
• Who will have access to this information?
• How will this data be used to improve my care?
• Are these potential improvements worth the compromise to my privacy?

Ethical implementation hinges on transparency, collaboration, and a commitment to preserving the dignity of individuals living with dementia.

Sources

• The ethics of using location tracking technology with people living with dementia, The Conversation.

IntelligentHQ

Founder Dinis Guarda

IntelligentHQ Your New Business Network.

IntelligentHQ is a Business network and an expert source for finance, capital markets and intelligence for thousands of global business professionals, startups, and companies.

We exist at the point of intersection between technology, social media, finance and innovation.

IntelligentHQ leverages innovation and scale of social digital technology, analytics, news, and distribution to create an unparalleled, full digital medium and social business networks spectrum.

IntelligentHQ is working hard, to become a trusted, and indispensable source of business news and analytics, within financial services and its associated supply chains and ecosystems